Is It Still Worth Having an Umbrella Company in 2025?

With changes in legislation, evolving contractor working patterns, and shifting tax policies, many professionals are asking: Is it still worth using an umbrella company in 2025? In this article Umbrella Search examines the pros, cons, and latest developments to help you decide whether an umbrella company remains the right choice for your contracting career.

The Current State of Umbrella Companies in 2025

Umbrella companies have long been a popular option for contractors working inside IR35 or those who prefer a hassle-free payroll solution and not ready to expand with a limited company yet.

However, with increased scrutiny and regulation in recent years, including compliance crackdowns and tax rule adjustments, contractors must weigh their options carefully.

Key Changes Influencing Umbrella Companies in 2025

Several factors have shaped the landscape for umbrella companies this year, including:

• Stronger Regulation – The UK government has introduced stricter compliance rules to tackle tax avoidance schemes and ensure fair treatment of workers. HMRC continues to crack down on unethical umbrella companies using disguised remuneration schemes.

• IR35 Enforcement – More end clients are applying strict assessments, reducing the number of contractors operating outside IR35. This means that many professionals are left with no choice but to use an umbrella company if they want to remain compliant.

• Cost of Employment – Rising employment costs, including Employer’s National Insurance Contributions (NICs) and the Apprenticeship Levy, mean that contractors see a lower percentage of their gross pay. Some contractors are considering whether the benefits of umbrella employment outweigh the financial burden.

• Limited Expense Claims – Changes to tax relief rules continue to make umbrella companies less attractive for those wanting to claim work-related expenses. Since tax relief is generally only available for temporary workers who do not work at the same location for more than 24 months, many umbrella contractors miss out on this benefit.

• Transparency Issues – Some umbrella companies still lack clarity in how they calculate take-home pay, leading to concerns about hidden costs. Contractors must be extra cautious when selecting an umbrella provider.

Advantages of Using an Umbrella Company in 2025

Despite the challenges, umbrella companies still offer several benefits:

1. Hassle-Free Payroll

One of the biggest reasons contractors choose an umbrella company is simplicity. Contractors receive a regular salary with taxes and National Insurance deducted automatically, eliminating the need for self-assessment tax returns. This makes life much easier for professionals who prefer to focus on their work rather than financial administration.

2. Employment Rights

Unlike limited company directors, umbrella workers benefit from holiday pay, sick pay, pension contributions, and maternity/paternity leave. These rights can be particularly useful for those who require financial security during periods of leave or illness.

3. IR35 Compliance

Since tax is deducted at source via PAYE, contractors working inside IR35 do not need to worry about IR35 investigations or tax liability issues. This makes umbrella companies a preferred choice for those operating in industries where IR35 compliance is strictly enforced.

4. Easier Contracting

Short-term contractors, those moving between roles, or those unsure about forming a limited company find umbrella solutions more convenient. Since the umbrella company acts as an employer, contractors can switch assignments without worrying about setting up and closing a business.

5. Continuous Employment

The umbrella company acts as a single employer, which can be beneficial for mortgage applications and financial stability. Lenders often prefer borrowers with continuous employment records, which can make it easier to secure a mortgage compared to those operating through a limited company.

Start Now

Disadvantages of Using an Umbrella Company in 2025

While umbrella companies simplify administration, they come with drawbacks:

2. Employer’s National Insurance Deduction

This cost is taken from the contractor’s rate, reducing net income. Many contractors are unaware that this deduction is made before their salary is processed, which can come as a surprise.

3. Limited Tax Efficiency

Unlike limited company contractors who can distribute income through salary and dividends, umbrella workers are taxed as employees. This means that higher earners may lose a significant portion of their income to tax and NI.

4. Service Fees

Umbrella companies charge a weekly or monthly margin, which can add up over time. While some provide additional benefits such as insurance cover, these costs still reduce overall earnings.

Who Should Consider an Umbrella Company in 2025?

Using an umbrella company is still worthwhile if you:

• Are inside IR35 and cannot operate tax-efficiently through a limited company

• Want to avoid the administrative burden of running a business

• Prefer the security of employee benefits, including statutory entitlements

• Work on short-term contracts or are unsure about contracting long-term

• Need continuous employment records for financial applications (e.g., mortgages)

When Might a Limited Company Be a Better Option?

If you:

• Work outside IR35 and can operate as a limited company director

• Earn a higher day rate and want to maximise tax efficiency

• Are comfortable managing company accounts and compliance

• Want to retain control over financial decisions Then running a limited company may still be the better long-term option.

How to Choose the Right Umbrella Company in 2025

If you decide that an umbrella company is the best option for you, choosing a reputable provider is crucial. Look for an umbrella company that is:

• FCSA or Professional Passport accredited – Ensuring compliance with UK tax and employment laws

• Transparent about fees and deductions – Avoid any provider that withholds financial details

• Well-reviewed by contractors – Check independent reviews and testimonials

• Offering compliant payslips – Beware of schemes that promise unrealistic take-home pay

Final Verdict: Is It Still Worth It?

Umbrella companies remain a viable and compliant option for contractors in 2025, particularly those working inside IR35 or seeking a simple, low-maintenance payroll solution. However, the financial impact of umbrella fees and deductions means that contractors should carefully compare their options.

For those who meet the criteria for operating outside IR35, a limited company structure remains the more tax-efficient approach. Ultimately, the best choice depends on your contract status, income level, and long-term career plans.

Before making a decision, always seek advice from a trusted accountant or financial advisor to ensure you choose the best setup for your needs in 2025.

Which industry are you contracting in?

• IT & Tech
• Finance
• Medical
• Other